Sugar Free Gummy Bears: 2 Easy Ways to Make Them at Home
In short
Sugar free gummy bears are a handy low carb snack for when you get that little pang for something sweet. I show two methods. The quick, cheap one uses a sugar free jelly mix (Jell-O, depending on where you are) with about 3 tablespoons of extra gelatin and just under 150 ml of boiling water. My favourite gives you more control: about 4 tablespoons of gelatin, a similar amount of monk fruit sweetener, boiling water and a few drops of flavoured food colouring. Either way, you fill a gummy bear mould with an eye dropper and let them set. The amount of gelatin is what decides how firm they turn out.
Key points
- Two ways to the same result. A quick version with a bought sugar free jelly mix, and a version you make from scratch with gelatin and sweetener.
- Gelatin sets the texture. Jelly made the normal way is too loose to feel like a gummy bear. Add extra gelatin and experiment until the consistency suits you.
- Method one is cheap and fast. Sugar free jelly mix, about 3 tablespoons of gelatin and just under 150 ml of boiling water. The catch is the artificial sweetener in the jelly mix, which I’m not real keen on.
- Method two is my favourite. About 4 tablespoons of gelatin and a similar amount of monk fruit sweetener, which is like granulated sugar but a little less sweet. I don’t get on with stevia at all.
- Flavour with coloured flavouring. A few drops is enough. I went caramel butterscotch, and raspberry is pretty good as well.
- Plan ahead for the mould. You’ll need a gummy bear mould and an eye dropper. The moulds are easy to find online.
- Speed is of the essence. The mix starts to set quickly, so work fast, and rinse the jug and eye dropper straight after or you’ll never get it out.
- Don’t go overboard. Even sugar free sweets aren’t something to eat by the kilo.
When you get that little pang for something sweet, these are a good thing to have on hand. Make a batch, keep them in the pantry or the fridge, and grab a few when the urge hits. The grandkids love them too. They think they’re getting a treat, but it’s not doing them any harm. Just don’t tell them they’re healthy.
Method in brief
Method one: the quick way
You’ll need: a packet of sugar free jelly mix (Jell-O), about 3 tablespoons of gelatin, boiling water, a gummy bear mould and an eye dropper.
- Mix the jelly crystals and gelatin in a jug.
- Add boiling water to just under 150 ml and stir well with a fork.
- Smush any lumps of gelatin until they disappear. If you can’t, take them out or avoid picking them up with the dropper.
- Fill the mould with the eye dropper. Work quickly, because the mix starts to set fast.
- Rinse the jug and dropper straight away.
- Set. Leave them alone, or pop them in the fridge to firm up a bit quicker. They don’t take long.
Method two: my favourite
You’ll need: about 4 tablespoons of gelatin, about the same amount of monk fruit sweetener, boiling water, a few drops of flavoured food colouring, a gummy bear mould and an eye dropper.
- Combine the gelatin and monk fruit sweetener in a jug.
- Add boiling water and keep it moving so it doesn’t start to set. If it gets too tight, add a bit more water.
- Flavour it with a few drops of flavoured colouring. I used caramel butterscotch.
- Get rid of the lumps, then fill the mould with the eye dropper.
- Set. After half an hour or so, mine popped straight out of the mould. No dramas.
Which method should you use?
The jelly mix version is the cheap, quick and easy option, but sugar free jelly uses some sort of artificial sweetener, and I’m not real keen on those. The gelatin and monk fruit version takes about the same effort and gives you more control over the sweetener, the flavour and the firmness, which is why it’s my favourite. With both, the more gelatin you add, the firmer they get, so experiment until they’re how you like them.
A word on overdoing it
While I was looking into different ways to make these, I came across the Haribo challenge: people eating a kilo of sugar free Haribo bears and then spending the next week on the toilet. Let’s just put it that way. Sugar free doesn’t mean you can be stupid about it. A few gummies when you get a craving is the idea.
More sugar free treats
If you’re after more ways to handle a sweet tooth, have a look at my top 20 low carb snacks, the sugar free chocolate mousse, low carb crème brûlée (also made with monk fruit sweetener), low carb sugar-free brownies and sugar free ice cream that scoops.
Wondering why sugar is the first thing I cut? Read sugar, sugar everywhere, see what happens when you stop eating sugar, and grab the free Carb Guide. There’s nothing to buy and nothing to sell. I’m just sharing what worked for me.
New to all this? Watch my story and how I lost 23kg in four months.
Related on the blog
Not medical advice. I'm not a doctor, dietitian or nutritionist, just a bloke telling the story of what worked for me. Check with your doctor before changing your diet or medication.


