How to Make Sour Gummies at Home: Easy Sugar Free Recipe

· 6 min · Watch on YouTube

In short

After my original gummy bear video, a few people asked about sours, so here they are. It’s the same idea with one secret ingredient: citric acid. I use a packet of no sugar jelly mix (Jell-O, depending on where you come from), this time lime, because the citrus flavour goes really well with the citric acid. To that I add 2 and a half tablespoons of gelatin and a tablespoon of citric acid, then boiling water. Smush out the lumps, fill a gummy bear mould and let them set, generally a couple of hours on the bench, or quicker in the fridge.

Key points

  • Citric acid is the secret. That’s what gives them the sour kick. I used a tablespoon.
  • Lime works a treat. A citrus jelly flavour goes really well with the citric acid.
  • Gelatin firms them up. I went 2 and a half tablespoons of gelatin with the jelly mix to stiffen it up a bit.
  • Deal with the lumps. Smush the gelatin lumps out. There’s not much you can do to avoid them, and sieving them out just leaves you with less gelatin and softer gummies.
  • Taste as you go. Mine had a nice little kick.
  • A couple of hours to set. Leave them on the bench, or pop them in the fridge to set a bit quicker.
  • Clean up straight away. Gelatin will set inside the eye dropper and your jug if you leave it.
  • Handy to have around. A great no sugar treat for the kids, and a couple of these sorts out that little sugar rush urge.

If you’ve watched my sugar free gummy bears video, you’ll know how easy these are. A few people asked about sours, and it turns out it’s super simple. Same deal as before, just with a bit of citric acid thrown in for that tang. Even I can do it.

Method in brief

You’ll need: a packet of no sugar jelly mix (Jell-O), 2 and a half tablespoons of gelatin, a tablespoon of citric acid, boiling water, a gummy bear mould and an eye dropper.

  1. Mix the jelly crystals, gelatin and citric acid in a jug. I used lime jelly.
  2. Add boiling water and stir.
  3. Smush out the gelatin lumps as best you can.
  4. Taste. You’re after a nice little kick.
  5. Fill the mould with the eye dropper.
  6. Rinse the jug and dropper straight away, before the gelatin sets in them.
  7. Set. Leave them on the bench, or put them in the fridge to set a bit quicker. Generally a couple of hours and they’re as good as they’re going to get.

Why bother?

These are a great no sugar treat for kids. They don’t even know they’re good for them. They’re also just handy to have in a little bowl lying around, so when you get the little sugar rush urge, you can grab a couple and Robert’s your mother’s brother, as they say. I’m not sure how long they keep, because they don’t last that long around here.

More sugar free treats

For the original version, including the one I make from scratch with gelatin and monk fruit sweetener, see my sugar free gummy bears. If you’re after more ways to handle a sweet tooth, have a look at my top 20 low carb snacks, the sugar free chocolate mousse, low carb sugar-free brownies and sugar free ice cream that scoops.

Wondering why sugar is the first thing I cut? Read sugar, sugar everywhere, see what happens when you stop eating sugar, and grab the free Carb Guide. There’s nothing to buy and nothing to sell. I’m just sharing what worked for me.

New to all this? Watch my story and how I lost 23kg in four months.

Related on the blog

Not medical advice. I'm not a doctor, dietitian or nutritionist, just a bloke telling the story of what worked for me. Check with your doctor before changing your diet or medication.

Carb Survivor Daily · free

Get the 2-page "How many carbs?" fridge guide

Traffic-light carb counts per 100g for the foods you actually cook with, plus a short email most days with recipes and what I'm learning. Unsubscribe any time. No spam, ever.

Your details are never shared or sold. Privacy.